Posted by: Admin on: August 15, 2008
Source : Reality of Shabaan
Rasool Allah saw said: “Who ever knowingly attributes a lie to me then he should make his abode in hell” ( Bukhari)
The following are some of the weak and fabricated hadiths and saying about Shabaan which are famous and are narrated frequently and are attributed to Prophet Muhammad (saw). Weak Hadiths and fabricated hadiths should not be quoted as hadiths as it is equivalent to attributing a lie to Rasool Allah (saw) and is a major sin.
May Allah have mercy on us all. All of the above mentioned hadiths on fasting and doing worship at night on the 15th of Shabaan are Weak (Daif) and unauthentic. We should be very clear that there isn’t a single “Sahih” hadith about this day which may be used to accept and recognize these acts of worship.
Considering the status of these hadiths it can be stated that fasting especially on the 15th of shabaan and doing worship during the night of 15th of shabaan is an extreme innovation (Biddat) which has no basis whatsoever in the sunnah and should be avoided.
RELATED POSTS:
[...] Weak and Fabricated Hadiths regarding the 15th of Shabaan. [...]
Different imam’s have different criteria to judge if a hadith is Mutawatir, Sahi, Good or Weak.
There are basically two things you need to look to Judge a hadith… Isnad and Matn
Isnad refers to the completeness of the chain of narrators and the reputation of each individual narrators within the chain of oral tradition that goes back to the eye witness of the act or saying of Muhammad.
The matn refers to the text of narration. Even if there were a technical flaw in a hadith, it does not necessarily mean that the hadith is not an authentic one. Authenticity and weakness are two different concepts.
Usually Hadith having 4 or 5 strong chains Is regarded as ‘Mutawatir’, which is said to be the most Authentic form of Hadith, and which are quite few.
We should keep in mind that Sahi Bukhari and Sahi Muslim or any book of hadith is book made by man which is bound to have mistakes. Also the work done by Imam Bukhari and Imam Muslim was not to compile only the authetic hadith, but to compile all the hadith (good or bad) wherever they can get it from.
Allah Knows Best.
Jazakallah
Asslamu Aleikum.I think we should all take the posted ahadith and do a thorough research regarding on their authenticity. Anyone interested in knowing more of these weak narrations, please contact me at elshaabaz@gmail.com or
+254720556672.
Ramadhan Karim.
August 18, 2008 at 5:24 am
wow, but should we avoid everything in a weak hadith?? It also depends on the origin of the hadith and also the reason why they are weak.